portwood wrote:portwood wrote:Zunak wrote:There are 9 bottles there that I would never purchase again.
In decreasing level of confidence:
Glen Garioch 12
Arran Robbie burns
(what is behind the Springbank 10 - bowmore?)
Let's try again. Remove the Glendronach 12, replace with Ardmore traditional cask. (the logic being that as a peat man, the ardmore does not hold a candle to your stash of Ardbeg, Laphoraig, and others. the dronach may be the best sherried example on the list)
Do I get the house back?
Nope. The Glendronach is the worst tasting whisky I have ever had the misfortune of buying. I absolutely hate it. It would be the first to go. I really actually like the Ardmore as it has a different peat to it than the Islays and it is very well priced here in Canada. I'll give you a hint your logic for choosing the Ardmore was sound you just picked the wrong one....... Soooooo, one to go, one to stay, and one that I'd buy in a heartbeat. Any more guesses????